Housebound to Hopeless: Systemic failures in provision increased my risk of becoming NEET | At Our Pace

Today, the independent review into Young People and Work 'From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation' led by Alan Milburn has been published. Following on from our earlier blog 'Young People Do Not Become NEET Overnight' one Youth Advocate Lucinda, age 19 shares her story that demonstrates how systematic failures left a highly motivated, intelligent young person with Long Covid Not in Education, Training or Employment (NEET) despite her constant and exhausting self advocacy.
By 14, I was already being written off by SEND Services at my school - the advice?
“Just get through your GCSEs and then sign onto benefits.”
As a straight-A student my entire life, I found that a very hard pill to swallow. All I was
receiving at the time - taken from my bed - was 30 minutes of online tutoring in foundation Maths and English each day from my lovely local Pupil Referral Unit (a type of state-funded school for people with medical, SEND or social needs - that no one seems to have ever heard of).
However, I was taking Higher Maths and Sciences, with English and a couple other GCSEs to boot, which meant the PRU physically had no teachers to give me. Despite being struck down with Long Covid in Year 8, I wasn’t admitted to the PRU until the end of Year 9, effectively leaving me a year with no education. My original school couldn’t provide any online lessons outside those offered when the entire country was in lockdown.
On top of that, because I was housebound and couldn’t get to school, I had basically no interaction with anyone my own age for the entire time I was doing my GCSEs - I was a class of 1 in a school of 20. That isn’t to complain - the staff were all lovely to me - but I hope it shows just how lonely the road gets at a time people and media alike paint as when young people flourish in friendships and grow meaningful bonds with peers.
All being said, no one expected I could achieve 9988876 (5A*, 1A and 1B in old-school
terms) in my GCSEs purely through teaching myself the rest of the content from YouTube while housebound - yet I did.

Under The Education and Skills Act 2008, the participation age (the age of which you are expected to finish receiving education) was raised to 18, yet the provision for a Pupil Referral Unit only runs until the end of Year 11 at age 16, leaving disadvantaged pupils like myself with little to no options after being rejected by further education institutions.
The traditional advice failed me:
Apply to more places? I did.
Be flexible with courses? I did.
Get better grades in your GCSEs? I did.
All of the colleges I applied to told me some flavour of the same thing:
We like you, we like your grades, but you can’t make it in every day so we can’t take you.
Imagine the look on my face when a seemingly high achieving student got rejected from every A-Level offer she applied to.
Luckily, my original brick-and-mortar offered to keep me purely on the books on the condition that I would apply for an Education Health and Care Plan (EHCP) - which I’ll get to in a minute. My Sixth Form journey didn’t get off to a great start - in fact, it was almost comical. I was told I could come in for the first day, but I would have to get myself around with no support, and my tutor room was six flights of stairs up in a building with no lift. Now, I’m not a rocket scientist, but I’m pretty sure that wasn’t going to work. So this also meant it was back to self-teaching from YouTube...again. Yay (!)
Under Section 36 of the Children and Families Act 2014: The local authority must secure an EHC needs assessment for the child or young person if, after having regard to any views expressed and evidence submitted under subsection (7), the authority is of the opinion that—
(a) the child or young person has or may have special educational needs, and
(b) it may be necessary for special educational provision to be made for the child or
young person in accordance with an EHC plan.
Despite being in alternative provision for 3 out of the 5 years of my secondary education, apparently I did not meet the threshold for assessment by my local council, which required I go to mediation.
The bureaucracy of the system meant the mediation company could only speak to me about my records as a 16 year old (at the time), but simultaneously had to ask my parents permission to speak to me as I was under 18.
To add to the frustration, the council were so slow to respond, the mediation certificate was written automatically. In the meantime, my appeal was being passed from caseworker to caseworker, and replies to my emails were infrequent and futile in response - this isn’t just my area either, I’ve heard stories of young people across the country being de-facto ignored by councils buried under rising demand from new applications and appeals.
Either way, I was at high risk of becoming NEET - something all local councils are meant to prevent under Section 68 of the Education and Skills Act 2008 - and yet, I still had to fight to be assessed. By the time they assessed and determined I did - in fact - need an EHCP, I was nearly halfway through Year 12, yet the advice was still the same as when I was younger:
“Just take anything to get through, and sign onto benefits when you get out of school.”
I had done everything right - got good grades, proved myself, applied through the correct channels, self-taught, took the responsibility on my own head to push this through...and yet, that was the only advice anyone could offer?
There was only one school in the country - an online school - that could take me, as I was housebound, and it meant having to switch one of my subjects again (as if I hadn’t done enough swapping and changing by now) - but what else could I do?
That’s what life is like with Long Covid: a constant cycle of being failed by something,
fighting for what you deserve, the fight going on so long you end up turning into a
pseudo-legal professional, and conceding to something less than you needed because you want your peace back at some point.
The rest of my Sixth Form education was fine, really - I was shocked when nothing had
really gone wrong for the last 18 months in education (except being locked out of my school account for a month because the council forgot to re-enroll me, but that was a minor setback compared to what I had been through by this point), although a further Covid reinfection meant a period of rest and having to catch up when my health allowed.

By the time results day came around, I was one of the only ones in my class that surpassed their predicted grades, with two of my three grades being A* and A.
This was despite my OT (Occupational Therapist) telling me I was just “too stressed”, teachers well-meaningly pestering me about my lack of plans after school, and barely receiving the provision in my EHCP. It was a small miracle after the two years I’d had...but that was it.
No university, no job, no nothing. While everyone around me was heading off to Fresher’s Week, I had to contend that my future realistically looks like being called a ‘Benefit Scrounger’
(even by family and so-called friends), getting miffed glares from elderly people who clearly think ‘you’re too young to be in a wheelchair’, and my maximum salary being capped well below minimum wage - all the people who never believed in me were going to be right, no matter how hard I tried.
Everyone I explain my story to is shocked - how can someone who has done so traditionally well completely fall off a cliff edge at 18 when they leave school?
It’s simple, I’m housebound.
I’m not sure any person who says “make your own work” has seen the state of any job
boards or freelance platforms - any work requires about 20 years of experience as it is, and the second you mention remote working, you’ll never hear from the recruiter again. To add to that, anything that can be done remotely can be outsourced, making it a race to the bottom for minimal pay. I tried freelancing literally any job that I could do and I’m lucky to make £40 in a month (and only by attempting to work more hours than my health really allows) , but hey - make your own work, am I right?
I registered as self-employed as a) I legally had to anyway and b) I hoped it would give me more credibility among other young people - especially since saying ‘I’m unemployed and don’t leave the house’ sounds horrendous as an introductory line.
As for other sources of income...there’s really not much. With not being eligible for Universal Credit or New-Style ESA, and already claiming PIP (which is designed for extra costs due to disability, not to live on), I am pretty much stuck. Believe it or not, £700 a month really isn’t that much to live on, especially if I ever wanted to live independently - it doesn’t even cover a room in a shared house with bills.
Ever since the local council - who mysteriously forgot about me since I finished school,
despite having an EHCP - found out I was NEET, they’ve been on at me about getting into consistent work with an employer. Apparently, self employed work isn’t good enough, because I’m not a payroll employee - what a way to be restrictive.
Trying to be helpful, they suggested supported employment, with the only options being in-person placements. While these are good for people with learning disabilities, there is no current offer for people who can only do remote working like myself - it just comes back to the same thing...go on benefits, the ones that pay just under 50% of minimum wage.
It was also suggested I get an access to work grant - despite being disabled, I am not eligible for this - to claim as a self employed person, you need to earn
over £5,600 a year in revenue, which I don’t make.
I don’t earn enough to be eligible for a grant to access work to help me earn more - you really couldn’t make this up.
It’s infantilising to say the least, and dangerous to say the most. When chronically ill people are physically reliant on others, it reduces them to a state where they will always have to remain on low-income to claim. It puts people like myself in a situation where we will always have to rely on others for basic living, even if we were capable of doing it ourselves.
It also disadvantages us longer term, with young people who are NEET for sustained periods suffering significantly lower earnings than non-NEET peers. Every aspect of our futures is affected, from having no workplace pension scheme to not being able to take out a mortgage (and hence have ownership of a home - although that appears to be more of a self-employed thing, as it’s not seen as a real job.
It’s incredibly tough to even get a credit-builder credit card, as people on disability benefits - or any benefits for that matter - are seen as higher risk customers. Being failed consistently by the system also means having to use limited savings to self-fund mobility equipment - I’m still using a six-year-old, falling apart wheelchair that was placed on my parent’s credit card during lockdown.
Constantly looking over your shoulder in public is terrifying in itself - having to watch for people who are scanning to see if you have a motability car just because you have a Blue Badge, watching what you post on social media because an armchair detective believes they know more than fully qualified doctors - and half the time, even the doctors are dismissive. Living with a chronic illness means being in constant fear that someone will send a malicious report to the DWP because they saw you standing up once in public and immediately believe you’re committing benefit fraud.
While I make the entire journey out to be doom and gloom - because a lot of the time, it is - there were some fun bits and amazing people along the way. You learn to appreciate the small things more - the tutors at my PRU, my wonderful Head of Year, performing in my Sixth Form showcases, and the teachers (that know who they are) who never stopped believing in me. When you face a fight against the system for daily survival, the small things are often the only ones you have left.
That being said, I’m just one young person. One girl who self taught most of her GCSEs, one girl who nearly had to single-handedly take her local council to tribunal at 16 years old, one girl who still doesn’t have a long term plan because no system is there to support her.
It does make me wonder, though - how many Mums and Dads, Aunties and Uncles, Grandmas and Grandpas are sat sobbing at their kitchen table because their appeal got denied for their bubbly but unsupported kid? How many protests outside Parliament never impact the Punch-and-Judy displays of the Parliament front benches? How many young people look up at the people ahead of them and question “What is the point?”.
I haven’t escaped the system now I’m an adult (officially, anyway) - I’m still gaslit by doctors on the regular, insulted by well-meaning-but-misinformed friends, lied about by the DWP, forgotten about by the SEND system, and sick of the bureaucracy that means it takes 3 months to get a parking badge I’m automatically entitled to.
However, if even one person reads this blog - one SEN teacher, one researcher, one
Occupational Therapist, Parliamentarian or Department of Work and Pensions Caseworker and decides to meet the young person where they are, it can make just one aspect of a lifelong systemic struggle that bit easier.
If you’re a young person reading this and you resonate with any part of my story, I
just want to tell you to keep fighting. It may not seem worth it at times - and I know it’s cliche to say - but even if it’s just for the purpose of sticking it to the man, your voice deserves to be heard in a world increasingly trying to turn humans into statistics.
I may still be stuck at home after all these years, and who knows if I’ll be able to go out for anything other than a hospital appointment again or be able to earn a liveable wage, but my laptop and I can at least try and take on the world from where we are.
Huge thank you to Lucinda for sharing her challenging personal experience.
The independent report does talk about disabled young people and the additional challenges they may face, echoing Lucinda - and many more of our members' experiences. It also recognises the extraordinary resilience that many of them are forced to develop fighting against systems that fail them. We remain concerned about how the proposed reduction in benefits and alternatives to PIP and health-related UC are implemented and how they will ensure that those who are currently too unwell to work are not pushed further into poverty.
Chapter 4: Education - the bridge to the future and Chapter 5: Health - the foundation to participation are particularly relevant and discuss what additional support will need to be provided to young disabled people. Long Covid Kid's new resources for Education and Health provides key learning for these areas to support their work with children and young people with Long Covid, and our asks on the previous blog post remain relevant to ensure the needs of children and young people with Long Covid and overlapping conditions are properly considered and supported as part of any future reform.
Employability skills is also the focus of current and upcoming Occupational Therapy students under the supervision of our Health Lead Kirsty Stanley. More to come on this before the end of the year.



